Watchlist This! our May 2025 picks of the best new bubbling-under films

Our picks of under-the-radar gems from this month’s new releases. This edition includes a tropical Brazilian noir, a Scott Pilgrim-esque coming-of-ager, a history-making character study and a couple of expectation-subverting horrors.

Featuring: Motel Destino, Egghead & Twinkie, Electra, The Surrender, Vulcanizadora, The Fishbowl

It’s gonna be/is May, which means that the Cannes Film Festival is officially in full swing. Our crew will be on the Croisette hunting down some juicy interviews and scouting out the most poppin’ premieres, so keep a close eye on our socials, and if you’re lucky enough to have made it out to the South of , look out for the Letterboxd mic!

However, if you’re feeling that Film Festival FOMO (FFF), make your own fun by programming a personalized fest with these watchlist recommendations. We’ve got a desire-drenched drama set in a Brazilian motel, a colorful teenage buddy-comedy about a lesbian animator and her himbo straight-guy bestie, a deeply personal Puerto Rican character study that artfully compares the corrosiveness of cancer with the rot of colonialism, a fashion-forward comedy-thriller and a couple of volatile horror films that toy with audience expectations.

This month’s picks come from Marya E. Gates, Zachary Lee, Leo Koziol, Dan Mecca and Rafa Sales Ross. Happy watchlisting!


Motel Destino

Directed by Karim Aïnouz, written by Aïnouz, Wislan Esmeraldo and Mauricio Zacharias.
Now playing in select UK and Irish theaters and streaming on MUBI in Latin America.
Strand Releasing (US)/Brouhaha Entertainment and Written Rock (UK)

After trying his hand at the British period drama with 2023’s Firebrand, Brazilian Algerian filmmaker Karim Aïnouz returns to the language—literally and aesthetically—of early-career works such as Madame Satã and Futuro Beach with Motel Destino. This tropical noir set in the piping hot northeastern region of Brazil finds 21-year-old Heraldo (Iago Xavier) on the run from a ruthless drug lord. Dazed and lost, he stumbles upon the titular roadside motel, finding not only a hiding place but also an unexpected romance with owner Dayana (Nataly Rocha), who long yearned for an escape from abusive husband Elias (Fábio Assunção).

Speaking to Letterboxd upon the film’s world premiere in competition at the Cannes Film Festival last year, Aïnouz says it was “really good to go back” to Brazil after five years. The filmmaker, like many of his colleagues, struggled to conceive of a thriving national cinema under the culture-averse Bolsonaro government (2018–2022). “Leaving Cannes after presenting Firebrand and flying back home was a moving experience to me because I didn’t think I was going to be able to keep making movies in Brazil,” he adds soulfully.

This ion for his homeland drips out of Motel Destino, an ode to the heat of the tropics, one that castigates the arid land but glistens bare bodies. Not_cool_bruh understands the sell perfectly: “Visually gorgeous, with a banger soundtrack, plus well shot. And very horny, too. What more could you want?” Other have tried to encapsulate the film’s throbbing sense of desire by anchoring it with references to Almodóvar, Gaspar Noé and even Luca Guadagnino, although Belén takes the cake by simply saying, “How hot!” Indeed!

Of the movie’s sensuality, Aïnouz describes “there is a real sense of life when someone is making love. Heraldo’s arrival brings light to Dayana’s life again, it makes her desire again. This is what I was looking for.” When asked about the film’s pristine sound design, a carefully curated cacophony of yearning, the director recalls how, the first time he visited a roadside motel for research, he was “surprised at how close you get to people.”

“You walk by the doors and you listen to the sounds,” he continues. ”The first time I heard it, I was embarrassed for them and for myself. Why does it make us feel uneasy? Cinematically, it’s interesting because there are things you imagine but don’t necessarily see. So we designed sound as a way to mirror this feeling.” If all of this hasn’t sold you, I don’t know what will. RSR

Egghead & Twinkie

Directed and written by Sarah Kambe Holland.
Now streaming on VOD in the US.
Tribeca Films

Crowdfunded via TikTok, writer-director Sarah Kambe Holland brings a delightfully Gen-Z video aesthetic to her feature directorial debut, the queer coming-of-age buddy-comedy Egghead & Twinkie. The film centers on teenage animator Twinkie (Sabrina Jie-A-Fa), who is on the cusp of college and has recently come out to her conservative parents. She convinces her bestie, Egghead (Louis Tomeo), to go on a summer road trip, without telling him that her main aim is to meet up with the Insta-famous DJ she has been secretly DMing. Along with its unique visual flourishes, heartfelt look at the growing pains of friendship as college looms in the near future, and the highs and lows of first love, Holland’s movie, which has just finished a two-year festival run, also features one of the year’s best roadside diner scenes.

With a banger soundtrack and a playful use of animation, more than one Letterboxd member has compared it with Edgar Wright’s Scott Pilgrim vs. the World. Other have praised the film’s central friendship, with Chlo writing, “I can’t lie, I eat ‘the lesbian and her straight best friend guy sidekick’ trope up so much that I’ll request it as my last meal.” Similarly, Achoo says that it made their “heart swell with high school feels and nostalgia.” Dino agrees, writing, “I wish I had had this movie as a teenager.” MEG

Electra

Directed by Hala Matar, written by Matar, Paul Sado and Daryl Wein.
Now playing in select US theaters.
Level 33 Entertainment

The first film directed by a Bahraini woman, music video director Hala Matar’s feature film debut Electra, a twisty pitch-black comedy of manners, stars Daryl Wein, who also co-wrote the script, as an eager journalist named Dylan who has traveled to Italy with his photographer/girlfriend Lucy (Abigail Cowen) to profile an eccentric fading rock star named Milo (Jack Farthing), who lives in a 15th century palazzo with his wealthy girlfriend sca (Maria Bakalova). Once Milo invites the couple to the opulent estate for the weekend, slowly we learn that Dylan and Lucy may not actually be who they seem. Matar’s playful use of subtitles, title cards and music gives the movie a very online video aesthetic feel.

Letterboxd have compared it to The Talented Mr. Ripley, as well as several recent “eat the rich” features like Saltburn, Bodies Bodies Bodies, The Menu and The Triangle of Sadness. Several viewers have praised the work of Oscar-nominee Maria Bakalova, whose “magnetic” presence Shane attributes with bringing the right vibes to Matar’s "stylish and flashy thriller” which “spices up some tropes with some strong filmmaking.” Others have pointed to the costume design—which included collaborations with Valentino, Versace and Bvlgari—as the film’s biggest strength: Sofnin writes that they are “forever envious of the wardrobe.” David agrees, proclaiming, “Lord Jesus the costume designer ATE!!!” MEG

The Surrender

Written and directed by Julia Max.
Streaming on Shudder May 23.
Shudder

Written and directed by Julia Max, The Surrender is spare, gruesome and unrelenting. When the patriarch of a family es away following a painful sickness, his wife (Kate Burton) and daughter (Colby Minifie) attempt to bring him back from the dead. It’s a ghoulish, foolish errand that can only lead to further pain. The fractured mother-daughter relationship sits at the center of this brutal, mournful piece of horror. Burton is great, while Juneau praises her co-star: “Brilliant performance by Colby Minifie, cuts deep.” Minifie does superb work from beginning to end, promising a rich career long after the end of the hit television series The Boys.

At its core, The Surrender is about the process of grief in all of its ugly undeniability. Louisa writes that it “strikes the perfect tone for the kind of meaningful horror it’s going for: a mix of the supernatural and a deeply personal story about grief and family.” The setting and production design is minimal here, and Max is smart to lean on her two leads to anchor the deceptively simple narrative. For many, parental figures are just that: figures, ideas, heroes and/or villains. Only with time and understanding do they become human beings. While the gnarly, truncated third act leaves something to be desired, The Surrender never wavers from its bold mix of fantasy and realism. This kind of ambitious tone speaks well of Julia Max and what she’s got in store for us in the future. DM

Vulcanizadora

Written and directed by Joel Potrykus.
In select US theaters May 2.
Oscilloscope Laboratories

Ruminating on the destabilizing sadness of middle-aged crises (and the sinking feeling that we may never overcome our worst mistakes), Joel Potrykus’s Vulcanizadora mixes midwestern malaise, death metal and nauseating close-ups to spin a uniquely melancholy tale of male loneliness. It is a follow-up to Potrykus’ 2014 film Buzzard, though viewers can appreciate Vulcanizadora on its own . This one follows Marty (Joshua Burge) and Derek (Potrykus) who traverse through the Michigan forest, committed to a volatile pact. As they inch towards their destination, the two distract themselves through various antics (exploding Gatorade bottles, anyone?) occasionally filling the silences with offhand confessions around their dissatisfactions and regrets. Their plan implodes in more ways than one, and Potrykus’ film shifts from beholding sadness to working through its aftermath.

For Letterboxd , Vulcanizadora’s spiky tempo and narrative shifts not only kept them enthralled but left them emotional. “[It] starts off as a goofy movie about guys being dudes and descends into a deep depiction of shame and guilt,” Coolkidcort muses, while Chef Jeff confesses he “came in expecting a horror flick… and came out crying.” have found themselves asking existential questions in light of its release. “I think we all struggle so hard with internal guilt and the need to be free of it and we are never sure of how to escape it. Will death be a release?” Mel asks, while K8 bluntly shares, “Maybe there is no hell. Maybe we’re already there. It doesn’t matter, really. We’re all forced to grow up with it someday.” For Josh, there’s a sinister comfort in the ways Vulcanizadora’s aesthetic matches its somber mood, saying that it’s a film “as pugnacious as the understandably ostracized characters” leaving you “feel[ing]the desperation and doom closing in with each ing scene.” Feel bad cinema has never been more alive. ZL

The Fishbowl (La pecera)

Directed and written by Glorimar Marrero Sánchez.
Streaming on VOD May 21.
Monument Releasing

The cancer in Noelia (Isel Rodriguez) is reflected in the cancer in her native Vieques, Puerto Rico, whose people are still coping with the US Navy’s decades-long contamination of their land. Glorimar Marrero Sánchez’s debut feature The Fishbowl screened at Sundance 2023, but it’s been worth the wait for its US release. Since Sundance—where it was the first Puerto Rican feature to ever screen there—it went on to be nominated for a Goya Award, Spain’s equivalent to the Oscars, another first for Puerto Rico (the movie screened in International Drama at Sundance, not US Drama, because its co-producers were from Spain, a pointed tilt at its anti-US military sentiments).

The Fishbowl, or, La pecera, is an apt title, as it has a dreamy “through the looking glass” feel as Noelia floats in a bathtub at her home and then swims in her tropical home ocean at night. “Melancholic and laced with a very tangible sense of mourning,” writes Claira. “Cancer destroying an individual body falling in step with colonialism destroying the body of an entire population.”

Letterboxd interviewed Marrero Sánchez when her film came out at Sundance. “In 2013, my mother died of colorectal cancer,” she says. “So, I decided to write my first screenplay for a feature film, just to put the energy in a big project and develop a character that had her same sickness. I also wanted to talk about colonialism and human rights of Puerto Ricans, about sickness and colonialism.”

Lead actress Isel Rodriguez shines as Noelia. “Isel is mainly known in Puerto Rico as a comedian,” explains Marrero Sánchez. “The casting director said, ‘Let’s try her in a casting process just to see another level of her work,’ and it turned out to be amazing.” Rodriguez also has family links to Vieques: “The father of her two daughters is from Vieques.” The director continues, “She knew a lot about Vieques history because she’d been going to Vieques many years. She knew everything about sickness and the results of the water pollution and was very connected to the theme and the scenario.”

The Fishbowl has had a deep impact with viewers from Puerto Rico. “To someone else it might just be a movie about cancer and coming back home, but for those of us who are born and raised in Puerto Rico the root of the pain goes deeper,” says Jess. LK

Further Reading

Tags

Share This Article