In Pavements’ climax, its half-dozen threads are drawn together in an intricately cross-cut sequence, scored to a crescendoing pastiche of the group’s greatest non-hits. The soaring, operatic medley is perhaps, the maudlin, melodramatic pop form. Think only of Celine Dion or the Key & Peele sketch mocking Les Mis. Yet Pavements feels like it has earned the indulgence. It’s not a sudden, mawkish fishtail into earnestness. It’s almost as if Perry, Pavement, and their movie project have transcended irony and all that “jaded weltzschmertz” stuff and achieved a hard-won sincerity. It’s not just a doc-hybrid steeped in deep stew of cynicism and sardonicism. Rather, it marshals its many ironic techniques—the fake interviews and artifacts, the self-consciously “bad” Bohemian Rhapsody-style biopic—in the service of a totally heartfelt, meta-sincere message, which is, basically: Pavement rules. It is ironic only in the truest sense of exploring the space between what is said (or seen) and what is meant.
Wrote about this for The Baffler.